A classic approach to homemade salad dressing, French style and completely adaptable.
I can’t remember the last time I purchased a ready-made dressing. Making my own is one of the first things I learned how to do moving to France. I find the ritual of making the salad dressing to be one of spontaneous creativity as it is endlessly adaptable based on your mood or what is available. I personally never measure the ingredients, I just taste to make adjustments. Too much acid? Add more oil. Not enough flavor? Add more acid. I don’t make big batches in advance, I just make it fresh when I need it which is almost daily! The basic rule I follow is an acid and an oil, then salt and pepper. Everything else is up for interpretation.
The Basics
Three parts oil to one part acid. For the simplest and quickest dressings I don’t even mix- I just plate the lettuce (this works really well with arugula) squeeze lemon juice, drizzle olive oil, salt & pepper and it’s done. People always ask me “I love the dressing, what is it?” and it’s so ridiculously simple! For a classic French base it’s a vinegar mixed with dijon mustard, salt & pepper, then emulsified with olive oil.
Ingredients
ACID — Any vinegar is great. In France it is usually either a champagne vinegar, red wine vinegar, or “fruit” vinegar which you can find in abundance at the farmer’s markets. But I’ve also used rice wine vinegar for more asian flavor with a sesame oil, and of course, lemon is always good. Balsamic vinegar is wonderful, especially for tomatoes, or if you want more of an Italian flavor.
OIL — The most important thing is that you use a fresh olive oil. Olive oils don’t keep so buy something nice and use it. France, Spain, Portugal, Italy, and California make the best in my opinion. If you’re visiting France, buying a tin of locally pressed olive oil in Provence is a must-do take-home from any market. Aside from that, I love to mix half olive oil with half a nut oil. I think walnut oil is amazing for salads.
MUSTARD — Grainy mustard, smooth mustard, “hot” mustard- anything goes! I personally love to use a herb infused mustard. Tarragon mustard is especially nice for salads I find.
GARLIC & HERBS — If I add a minced garlic clove or two I’ll let it sit in the vinegar or lemon juice for a bit to take some of the bite off. You can also add shallot here as well instead of garlic. Minced herbs of any kind are amazing. Roasting your garlic adds a real umami flavor! When I roast a chicken I add garlic to the roasting pan and after it’s finished cooking I use the pan roasted garlic to make the salad dressing so it is very complimentary flavors.
SWEET — Adding a small amount of honey or maple syrup is a fun twist to add complexity without making it “sweet”.
Mixing Style
There are many ways to bring a salad dressing together. You can just dash some oil, vinegar, salt and pepper over the lettuce and call it a day if you’d like! Chefs like Alice Waters like to use a mortar and pestle (she sells her own artisan made version now in her daughter’s brand shop and you can find more affordable versions). I will use mine if I want a smooth dressing with the garlic invisible into the sauce. You can also use a mason jar to put all the ingredients in and simply shake to mix which makes keeping leftovers in the refrigerator if you want to make a larger batch easier. Most nights though I just use a simple small whisk and bowl and it works perfectly fine. I don’t stress too much about the emulsification, as French chef Jacques Pépin prefers it not perfect because he likes the mixed look of glossy oiled lettuce with flavor pockets of dressing.

The photograph of the Vinaigrette came from a cooking workshop I attended at Château de Gudanes with chef Julie Marr. Below is Julie’s recipe for her favorite french vinaigrette.




Jamie,
Merci tout plein
This is such a wonderful ‘expose’ on the Art of the Vinaigrette’.
Lynne
I am happy to share Lynne 🙂